Stuff
The top level ontology of the OpenGALEN model makes a primary distinction between structure and substance. In general, substances should be stuff-of structures. This distinction is not, however, without its tensions. In the case of haematemesis, is the blood stuff-of vomitus or portion-of it?
Odell states that the stuff-of relation is a subtype of the part-of relation. We have observed that it often also strongly implies a contained-in relation, particularly in the context of substance stuff-of liquid. (e.g. blood contained-in vomitus; sodium contained-in plasma). This led us to split stuff-of into made-of and mixed-throughout. Mixed-throughout is then a descendent of both part-of and contains through its direct, hybrid parent: partitvely-contains. It has further descendent links dissolved-in and suspended-in to represent the difference between a solution and a suspension or emulsion (water dissolved-in alcohol but water suspended-in oil).
Inheritance of stuff-of over other partitive semantic links also requires care. For example, the fat tissue within an eyelid can be viewed as being stuff-of the eyelid. Within the OpenGALEN model, however, the eyelid is itself separately given as a component-of the eye as an organ and a surface-of the face. This presented difficulties when considering the surgical procedure to resect that fatty tissue. When the stuff-of relationship is inherited over both the component-of and surface-of relations, this operation is classified as both a kind of eye surgery and facial surgery. This conflicts with usual convention and suggests that inheritance over both links is inappropriate.