Previous Next

Area and Containment

Our experience in the domain of anatomy confirm Odell's observation of an inconstant relationship between contains - true topological inclusion - and partonomy. The container may be treated as part-of the content (pericardial disease is a kind of heart disease; pleurisy is a kind of lung disease). Alternatively, the reverse may be true (colitis is a kind of abdominal disease) or there may be no partitive relationship between the container and its content (cerebral abscesses are not skull disorders).

Thus containment and partitivity should properly be modelled independently. However, for authoring economy and to work around limitations within the algorithm to expand GALEN intermediate representation into GRAIL, a hybrid relationship is used: partitively-contains - similar to Odell's area relation - to represent the case where the content is also considered to be part-of the container. This semantic link is given as a descendent of both contains and component-of such that the link subsumption hierarchy is a graph, not a tree. The impact of this convenience, and of a semantic link polyhierarchy more generally, on GRAIL’s compute performance is under review.

Literature

Winston, M., Chaffin, R., and Herrmann, D. 1987. A Taxonomy of Part-Whole Relations.
Cognitive Science, 11;: 417-444.

Odell, JJ. (1998) Six different kinds of aggregation.
In Advanced Object-Oriented Analysis & Design Using UML.
Cambridge University Press;:139-149

Previous Next
Making the impossible very difficult, ©OpenGALEN.org, All rights reserved