Arbitrary part
In our representations of surgical procedures and of diseases we encountered the notion of apparently discrete, well circumscribed and well understood structures whose parts are not related in the normal anatomical sense. For example, hand-foot-and-mouth disease (caused by Coxsackie A-16) is typically characterised by a rash that affects the hands, feet and mouth while sparing the structures in between. Several representational choices present themselves in this situation: is this one rash with multiple locations or three rashes with one location each?
We also experimentally considered one rash with one location, but this required a mechanism to represent the notion of a single, anatomical structure with component parts the hands, the feet and the mouth. We felt the component-of relation did not seem appropriate for this purpose and so a dedicated link arbitrary-part-of was created specifically for the purpose. Such a structure would be defined as:
ArbitraryBodyConstruct
which arbitrary-part-of hand
which arbitrary-part-of foot
which arbitrary-part-of mouth
..where ArbitraryBodyConstruct is the parent of all such structures. Similar structures might be head and neck, hand and wrist or retina and choroid but, although some of these are already present in the OpenGALEN model, their representations do not yet consistently use the ArbitraryBodyConstruct method.
A variant of this problem occurs with adjacent structures. We speak of A fracture of the tibia and fibula but would not talk of a single fracture of the femur and humerus. We normally expect a single fracture to have a single location, but for adjacent structures we allow it to have two. This contrasts with the rash example, where the locations of the rash are not required to be adjacent.