Previous Next

Obstacles to extensibility

Traditional systems can only be extended by reference back to their developers. Even if the concept is implied by the other concepts around it — a burn for a more detailed site or an infection by an unusual organism for example — it cannot be done automatically. Furthermore, the new concept must be placed in the hierarchies according to the existing conventions which is an error prone task, particularly if the system allows multiple classifications.

A major consideration is that changes should have no unanticipated side effects. Because traditional systems have little formal structure, there is little formal meaning to placing a concept at one point or another in the hierarchy and hence can be little formal verification of the effects of the changes. Because there are no standard semantics for software which uses such systems, there is no way to say what changes a given modification will cause to a given implementation. Paradoxically, the goal of flexibility in use can only be achieved by formal rigidity in structure which allows verification of the consequences of change.

Previous Next
Making the impossible very difficult, ©OpenGALEN.org, All rights reserved